
at home i blog more. mainly because i have mucho time to think.
anyway babel sucks.
babel got a whopping 7 nods at the golden globes. i am flabbergsted, a little astounded, with a smidgeon of flummoxed.
babel stinks because it's lifeless. because it's a pretty package with a pretty message that makes us comfortable with our pretty little lives. because even though terrible terrible things happen, it makes us sleep at night, because in the end, we realize, all the world's problems could be solved if we just GASP communicated a little better. i am enlightened.
it's ostensisbly challenging, supposed to shake our very foundations, make us realize the depth of the miscommunication and the fact that the world's getting so so far apart even with technology. yet it serves, mainly, to make us feel better. because gosh darnit, if only we could speak the same language, if we could just understand...well everything will be just peachy.
this kind of simple moralizing masks the fact that the world's problems are right fucking complicated. hey i'm all for more understanding. but a movie about the fact that we need to understand each other doesn't say anything at all. it might as well say the sky is blue. compare this with syriana. syriana shows the world sucks too. but that world is all the more real because really, what is your solution to that problem? what can save the world of syriana? you don't know and i don't either and that's the point.
but it's not the message of babel that's my problem. my problem is that every moment is supposed to be so poignant. poignant looks, poignant words, poignant imagery, poignant, poignant, poignant. good for poignant. this isn't a story. this is a bunch of talking heads talking nice little messages about our misunderstood little world. these are people. these are soapboxes. i know i sound like manny farber, but that guy really was onto to something...
so like crash, this movie is going to win best picture because it shows us the most sanitized version of the world's problems. when the little kid dies, it isn't raw, visceral, or powerful as the death of the child should. it looks like the confirmation of a message, a point, a thesis.
movies are supposed to make you stop breathing. the only time it happened during the movie was during the dance club scene when the music cuts out to show us the world of the deaf girl. that's the only time the movie clicked. because it wasn't about anything. and so in turn, it was about life. unlike the rest of the movie, which was about something, and thus about nothing.
i hope i'm not the only one feeling this way. i hope that somewhere out there is someone who will confirm that this movie, in fact, has no heart, only a gaping maw. the movie tries to show that if we all understood, if we all spoke with a more common and understandable voice, we'd all be saved. but it is the common message, the common voice of the movie telling us that the world needs more understanding that is the problem. i'd rather have this movie actually be the tower of babel. a thousand messages all at once, voices talking every which way. it'd feel more alive.